| Restorative
Justice stresses the importance of
relationships over and above rules. It seeks at
all times to restore the relationships between
people when these have been damaged by
inappropriate or offending behavior. This has
profound implications for any community that seeks
to embrace restorative principles - and none more
so than the school community where young people
are learning to be effective and reflective
citizens.
The
most well-documented applications
of Restorative Justice in schools to date are the
processes which seek to repair undisputed harm -
Restorative Conferencing, Family Group
Conferencing and Victim/Offender Mediation. These
are being used not only in cases of offending behavior
but also with young people who are at risk of
exclusion (or who have been excluded) as a way of
addressing the relationship issues and residual
tensions.
In
schools where Restorative Practices are being
used practitioners are discovering that other
issues can be dealt with restoratively, and these
may involve conflict where there is no 'guilty
party' or when both sides are blaming the other.
Mediation is often an appropriate response to such
situations, where neutral facilitators enable
those in conflict to listen to each other and find
a mutually acceptable way forward.
An
increasingly widespread application
of Mediation in schools is the development of a
Peer Mediation Service, usually run by young
people themselves who have been trained to mediate
amongst their peers and deal with conflicts that
arise in the playground. Successful schemes are
running in Junior and Secondary schools around the
UK and secondary aged students have their own
Young Mediators Network and run their own
conferences.
Such
schemes, however,
are less successful if mediation is not an
approach also used by the adults in the school
community. This is the message of a Restorative
Approach generally. It is important that
Restorative Justice is seen not simply as a
response to extreme behavior but that the
principles are in place in staff rooms, classrooms
and playgrounds every day.
It
would not make sense
to deal with some situations using one set of
values and then deal with other situations using
different values. Young people are quick to spot
hypocrisy and inconsistency. Justice is a very
important issue for them and they appreciate it if
the rules by which they are expected to live and
work in the school community also apply to adults.
Indeed a key restorative principle would be that
the whole community develop the rules together and
are involved in finding ways forward when these
rules are broken - whoever breaks them.
The
processes mentioned above require
certain skills of the facilitators but are also
more effective if participants are also practiced
in certain key Restorative Skills which include:
Active listening
Non-violent communication
Anger management
Conflict transformation skills
Dealing with difficult situations
Restorative de-briefing and reflective practice
Restorative
Justice is predicated on
the notion that damage has been done to
relationships by inappropriate behavior and that
prior to an incident there were relationships that
have subsequently been damaged. This may not have
been the case. In a school community relationships
and community need to be actively developed and
not taken for granted. This requires a set of
Relational skills and can be nurtured with certain
relational processes.
The skills include:
Active Listening
Self-awareness
Emotional literacy
Building rapport
Patience
Objectivity
Developing and maintaining self esteem
Appreciating difference
Inclusive practices
Expressing feelings and needs
The
Relational processes and systems,
which also develop the Active Citizenship skills
of the whole community, include:
Circle Time for Staff (for staff development, team
building and mutual support)
Circle Time for Students (for developing
self-esteem, communication skills and a spirit of
co-operation)
Healing Circles
School Council
Peer-counseling
Peer mentoring
Buddying Schemes
No-Blame Approach to Bullying
A Self-Esteem Policy for Staff and for students
A Whole School Relationship Management Policy (as
opposed to a 'Behaviour
Management' Policy that tends to focus on young
people's behaviour)
Pieced
together,
the Restorative and Relational processes and
skills described above make up the jigsaw of a
Whole School Restorative Approach. Every school
will have its own priorities and will want to
build on existing good practice. Time and
resources for training and support will also be
issues. For further information some useful links
to other websites are listed below:
Transforming
Conflict
- A Center for Restorative Justice in Education
.This organization is developing its own website
which will have information about Restorative
Issues in schools, details of courses , a
bibliography of useful books and a discussion
forum. It will be fully online by June 2001.
www.transformingconflict.org
Mediation
UK.
This is the umbrella organization for community
and victim/offender mediation services around the
UK. It also supports mediators working in schools
on Peer mediation projects.
www.mediationuk.org.uk
|